Tread carefully 窶ｦ

No comments

Most people don't know it, but floor coverings can be one of the most environmentally damaging parts of a building. Alex Smith investigates some methods and materials that should help stop us stomping on the environment

Floor coverings rarely feature prominently in articles on sustainable buildings. The writer will wax lyrical about sedum roofing, super-insulated cavity walls and photovoltaics, but floor coverings will be lucky if they get a mention in the suppliers list.

They deserve more attention. According to the Centre for Sustainable Construction at BRE, flooring finishes in a typical office can contribute up to a third of the total environmental impact of a building over a 60-year life (assuming a five-year replacement interval and a standard wool/nylon mix carpet with a foam backing) 窶� more than the roof, floor structure and walls put together (see right).

Soon manufacturers, architects and clients will have to examine the environmental performance of their floor specification more closely. Government legislation, rising landfill tax and demands from insurers and shareholders for greener, healthier buildings will force specifers to choose their floor coverings more carefully.

Some architects are already using environmental performance criteria for specification, such as BRE's Ecopoint system (see page 9). For example, London-based architect Architype carries out an environmental audit on all the materials it uses and aims to specify flooring with as low an environmental impact as possible (see case studies).

Manufacturers are also beginning to offer specifiers more sustainable options. BRE has just certified an environmental profile for Milliken Carpet and the commercial manufacturer is using this information to reduce the impact of its products and manufacturing processes on the environment.

It is also offering retextured carpet tiles to its European customers in a scheme called Earth Square. This aims to extend the life of a carpet, including its backing, by up to 20 years in order to save manufacturing resources and keep carpets out of landfill sites. Milliken's customers include Foster and Partners and the Environment Agency, which used retextured carpet at its offices in Cardiff (see "Tiles with air miles", page 10).

Milliken development director Dr Bill Tippett says that by the end of the year it will be as cost effective for its customers to return used carpets back to Milliken as it will be to dispose of them in a landfill.

The government's 1998 landfill tax is one of the main E E reasons large companies are now considering recycling. In 1998 a tax of ﾂ｣10 a tonne was introduced with an escalation of ﾂ｣1 a year to ﾂ｣15 in 2004/5. This is on top of the disposal costs of ﾂ｣20 a tonne. As a result, Tippett says he is getting increasing numbers of enquiries from corporate customers who wish to dispose of their carpet through Milliken.

Another commercial carpet company claiming green credentials is DuPont Antron, which has introduced a tool to measure the sustainability of its flooring. The Total Environment Impact Index takes into account factors such as emissions, health and safety, and water use and DuPont says it will use it to assess how it can improve the environmental performance of its nylon carpets.

Carpet maker Interface also has a green carpet scheme, called Evergreen Lease. Interface accepts responsibility for the maintenance and selective replacement of damaged tiles, which it claims prolongs the lifetime of the carpet.

Future legislation from the European Union will have an affect on the flooring specification. Certain types of PVC (vinyl) flooring are likely to come under the EU spotlight in the next few years when a new European chemical act demands that manufacturers justify some of the chemicals used in their products or replace them with less harmful materials (see "As green as grass?", overleaf).

Currently the amount of green flooring specification is largely confined to public-sector pilot projects and one-off private houses 窶� but there are signs that the corporate interest in the market is growing. GlaxoSmithKline has taken part in Milliken's Earth Square scheme (see "Tiles with air miles") and Canary Wharf has expressed an interest in carpets with a low environmental impact.

Developer Taylor Woodrow, meanwhile, is experimenting with sustainable modern flooring in its Green ｺﾃﾉｫﾏﾈﾉ￢V in Macintosh Village, Manchester. The building has 32 flats, a nursery and a doctor's surgery and will contain plywood Wisa flooring from Finnish supplier Schauman Wood.

The specifation of natural flooring is a trend that seems to be catching on among housebuilders. Copthorn Homes chose a natural sisal carpet for an apartment block in Penge, south London, at the suggestion of Construction Resources, an ecological building merchant that has spent years trying to get the sustainable message across to architects and builders.

The following case studies demonstrate some of the challenges faced by a specifier trying to build with green flooring materials, and there are also details on the first project in the UK to use retextured carpet tiles. Read on 窶ｦ

Treading softly: Claycots Primary School

Claycots Primary School in Slough proves how difficult it can be to specify sustainable flooring even when the client has a green agenda. Slough council wanted a school that would provide a sustainable template 窶� but although architect Architype was able to use Forest Stewardship Council-certified timber, a recycled aluminium roof and recycled newspaper insulation, it wasn窶冲 able to tick all the boxes labelled sustainable flooring. The architect was able to specify natural linoleum for the 11 new infant classrooms. It was slightly more expensive than the alternatives, but Architype was able to persuade the school and contractor that it was worthwhile because of its better environmental credentials. Elsewhere, however, cost constraints and practical considerations meant nylon carpet and PVC flooring was used, which have a larger environmental impact according to BRE窶冱 Ecopoint rating system. Local authority guidelines designed to protect children were responsible for some of the specifications: the client insisted on vinyl in bathrooms and toilets because of its non-slip attributes. In the classrooms that had sinks, the client was concerned that children could slip on the linoleum if it got wet. Architype had to ask linoleum supplier Forbo-Nairn to provide evidence that the covering would provide enough grip. 窶弩e窶况e been supplying linoleum for 15 years and never had any problems,窶� says director Bob Hayes. 窶廬 think the client was being careful because it was afraid of being sued if there was an accident.窶� Carpet made from man-made fibres was supplied for the shared areas and some classrooms. 窶弩e wanted to specify an eco-carpet,窶� says Hayes, 窶彙ut we went for a low-cost option because the head teacher was worried about the stains created by chewing gum and vomit. Schools would rather get a low-cost man-made fibre carpet that can be thrown away after five years rather than specify a better one that would last 25.窶� Hayes reckons a lot of schools subscribe to this way of thinking because they now control the purse-strings, rather than the local education authority. 窶弋he flooring now comes out of the same budget as the books,窶� he sighs. It窶冱 also harder to specify sustainable materials with a design-and-build contract, says Hayes. 窶廬n some cases, the products aren窶冲 necessarily any more expensive 窶� it窶冱 just the uncertainty that contractors don窶冲 like. They窶冤l whack on a premium for the perceived risk without even looking at the material.窶� Hayes also remarks that main contractors tend to charge more if they can窶冲 use their normal suppliers, as they aren窶冲 able to use their purchasing power. Hayes says he was happy with Architype窶冱 flooring specification, considering the cost constraints. The architect is currently working on the specification for the Eveline Low School in Southwark, south London. As the project is a green pilot scheme and involves the Department of Education, Hayes is hoping that more sustainable specifications will be accepted by the school and contractor. Suppliers:
Carpets Heckmondwike Spacord, Gradus Carewise
Vinyl Altro Walkway non-slip vinyl
Linolium Forbo-Nairn Marmoleum Real/Dual

Back to nature: Walsingham Lodge, Barnes, London

The use of naturally dyed wool carpet at Walsingham Lodge sheltered housing was driven by the architect, Architype. It pushed the benefits of the carpet to client Barnes Workhouse Trust and said the costs of the carpet including installation would fall within the budget of ﾂ｣24 per m2. Five new low-energy two-bedroom bungalows for the frail and elderly were constructed at the site, and 33 bedsits were converted into 21 one- or two-bedroom apartments. Fifteen one-bedroom bungalows were also refurbished. 窶廾ur difficulty was finding a natural wool carpet that could be used commercially,窶� says Dan Usiskin, director at Architype. 窶廴ost wool carpets are for domestic use.窶� Usiskin considered using coir and sisal but they were rejected because they were deemed more difficult to clean, and unsuitable for wheelchairs. The architect chose a weave over a pile carpet because it wanted to avoid the feel of a 窶彙oudoir窶�. The wool carpet was used in conjunction with a non-chemical, non-latex underlay called Gutex Happy Step. This is a wood-fibre insulation board that is laid below floor finishes such as timber, carpet or cork. It was chosen for its low embodied energy (the level of energy used in manufacture) and because its 6 mm depth provides impact sound resolution and warmth underfoot. Another aspect that Architype had to bear in mind was the effect of the sun on the carpet. It had to check the colourfastness of the dyes used with the manufacturer to ensure that the sun wouldn窶冲 bleach out the colour. In kitchens, bathrooms and toilets the local authority insisted that non-slip PVC surfaces be used. Suppliers:
Carpets (including underlay and adhesives) Construction Resources
Vinyl Altro Walkway non-slip vinyl Healthy living
Architype architect Catherine Harrington says the firm looks closely at the environmental performance of every material it uses. As well as using the BRE Ecopoint system to measure the impact of materials on the environment, Harrington has also devised additional criteria that consider the health affects of using a particular material. Harrington is looking at the consequences for health during the four stages of the product窶冱 life: manufacture; construction and installation; in-use and occupation; and disposal and re-use. Areas that may come under consideration will include toxins released during fires, off-gassing (the emission of gases during use), and the ability of the material to biodegrade.

Substructural flooring systems

This is an example of one of the flooring types covered by BRE窶冱 Ecopoint system. The best Ecopoint ratings for substructural floor systems have a relatively high environmental impact because they have to be engineered to take the weight of partitions, furniture and staff. The two raised floor systems have the highest overall embodied environmental impact. If the services were located in walls or ceilings, they would have a lower impact because the building would not require additional structural floors.

As green as grass? Floor covering credentials

PVC
PVC (polyvinyl chloride) is often used as a floor surface because it is inexpensive and easy to clean. The manufacture of vinyl is expected to be affected by forthcoming European Commission legislation, which aims to reduce the extent of harmful chemicals in the environment. Implementation will begin with the publishing of a list of 窶廚hemicals for Priority Action窶� in the next two years. Manufacturers will have to justify the use of these chemicals in their products. Materials often used in the manufacture of PVC likely to be on the list include lead, cadmium, organotins and phthalates. If they can窶冲 be justified, the EC proposes that less harmful materials should be used in PVC manufacture. Soft floor coverings
The Green Guide to Specification identifies those coverings requiring the least industrial processing as the best environmental performers. These include natural fibres such as sisal, jute, seagrass and wool. The worst are carpets with sponge or foam underlays and backings. A number of recent reports, including one by the University of Southampton, suggest that dust mites harboured in carpets cause asthma. This has been refuted by the Carpet Federation, which says asthma is just as likely to occur in countries where smooth flooring is more popular than carpet. Wood flooring
Surprisingly, many architects are still specifying exotic hardwoods when they could be using European timber from sustainable forests. Look out for wood certified by the Forest Stewardship Council and Pan-European Forest Certification. For installation solvent-free or low-emission finishes and adhesives are available. Natural linoleum
Linoleum is made from renewable material such as linseed oil, resin from pine trees and cork, which is mixed together with inorganic fillers such as clay and chalk. Expected lifespan is between 30 and 40 years. Natural rubber
A renewable source of flooring produced from the rubber plant. Durable and good at absorbing sound.

Tiles with air miles: The Welsh Environment Agency

The Welsh Environment Agency has specified 3000 m2 of retextured carpet for its new offices in Cardiff. The Milliken carpet tiles started life at the Stockley Park headquarters of pharmaceutical giant GlaxoSmithKline, where 13,000 m2 of the tiles were removed. The tiles were taken by Milliken in July and sent to the firm窶冱 factory in America where they were retextured, repatterned and cleaned. The tile backing was retained. Milliken calls the process Earth Square and is hoping that more firms will use the scheme in future 窶� either as donors, such as GlaxoSmithKline, or end customers. In the future Milliken hopes there will be enough customers in Europe to justify building a reconditioning plant in the UK. At the moment, to offset emissions caused by the environmentally incorrect practice of flying carpet tiles back to the USA, Milliken makes a donation to the Carbon Storage Trust to ensure the process is carbon neutral. The retextured tiles are half the price of new ones and come with a 10-year wear guarantee. Milliken development director Dr Bill Tippett says the tiles can withstand at least two retexturing cycles, giving them a lifespan of up to 30 years. When specifying the carpet, environment agency project manager Richard Hughes had to be aware of the carpet窶冱 previous incarnation. The tile窶冱 original base colours show through to the surface of the reconditioned tile so its important that any design takes this into consideration. At GlaxoSmithKline the carpet tile was beige with a green stipple 窶� at Cardiff it is now green and dark black. Dr Tippett says that though specifiers can choose colours, they should work with Milliken on the carpet pattern to integrate the colours with those of the original.