好色先生TV

For Hartcliffe Community College in Bristol, three triangular 鈥渟trawberry鈥� blocks are planned to house nursery, primary and secondary teaching spaces

The first scheme past the post in the government鈥檚 拢45bn 好色先生TV Schools for the Future programme promises pupils and teachers an inspiring educational environment. But then Skanska鈥檚 拢173m four-school scheme, which reached financial close with Bristol council last month, could be viewed as the exception to the BSF rule.

The 好色先生TV Schools for the Future programme has been drawn up by the Department for Education & Skills to build 3800 schools across the country over the next 15 years. It is conceived as a collection of framework agreements between local education authorities and private consortiums that fund, design, build and maintain the schools. But, in a trawl of the first 17 BSF projects, CABE warns the poor design standards of recent PFI and design-and-build schools could be repeated in BSF.

Poor design is not a criticism that can be levelled at Skanska鈥檚 Bristol scheme. The scheme鈥檚 great strength is its design by Wilkinson Eyre Architects, a practice that has twice won the Stirling prize and boasts a particular expertise in school design.

Three of the four schools are based on a standardised but distinctive form of classroom block devised by the architect in 2004 as one of the eight model 鈥渆xemplar designs鈥� commissioned by the DfES from top practices. Skanska鈥檚 team bolstered its credentials further by bringing in as educational adviser Graham Parker, formerly chief architect at the DfES school building division and who contributed to the same exemplar design.

Christened 鈥渢he strawberry鈥�, Wilkinson Eyre鈥檚 classroom block is a triangular deep-plan block with a rounded apex. It is a long-life, low-energy, adaptable building form. An 8.4 m deep strip running all round the perimeter is devoted to classrooms or other teaching spaces. The triangular core at the centre is a multipurpose zone that can be used as an IT-serviced study space for pupils spilling out from the classrooms.

This deep-plan configuration dispenses with corridors, as the multipurpose core doubles as circulation space. Not only does this save on building costs, but corridors are widely condemned by teachers as unsupervised spaces where pupils let rip with unruly behaviour and bullying.

The classroom strips have windows along one side only, which can provide natural ventilation for spaces not deeper than 7.5 m. But the strawberries are also equipped with rooftop ventilation flues towards the heart of the blocks that suck fresh air across deeper spaces without need for mechanical plant.

At Whitefield secondary school, a daylit internal mall serves as a circulation spine and is wide enough to encourage social interaction

The deeper plan enables the classrooms in the perimeter strip to be reconfigured as larger rooms without distorting them into an awkwardly elongated spaces. 鈥淭his makes for long-term flexibility,鈥� says Stafford Critchlow, director of Wilkinson Eyre.

The adaptability of the strawberry has been tested by Wilkinson Eyre at four different schools 鈥� Whitefield school, Brislington Enterprise College and Hartcliffe school in Bristol, plus the Madejski Sports Academy in Reading, currently under construction.

In the 1080-pupil Whitefield school, the three blocks contain all the teaching spaces, including technology labs and art studios. The other main building element in the Whitefield school is an elongated rectilinear block that contains the larger spaces such as a multipurpose hall and dining hall and ancillary rooms such as offices and toilets.

A wide daylit mall 鈥� rather than a narrow corridor 鈥� separates the elongated rectilinear block from the row of three strawberries.

In the more ambitious Hartcliffe school, at which pupils range from ages four to 18, strawberries were designed to serve as nursery, primary and secondary blocks.

However, Critchlow accepts the strawberry plan does not lend itself to tight inner-city sites. Instead, Speedwell school in central Bristol adopts a condensed configuration of angular forms offset from a central mall.

The average two-storey strawberry houses about 300 pupils, which education consultant Parker sees as the ideal size for a creatively interactive education establishment. 鈥淚n Chicago, they have found that the optimum size for secondary school is 350 pupils,鈥� explains Critchlow. 鈥淚n the UK, there is a drive for ever-bigger schools of 1000 pupils or more. So what we鈥檝e done here is to create smaller units within bigger schools.鈥�

The emphasis on design quality at Bristol emanated from the client. 鈥淲e made a great fuss about design right from the start,鈥� says Gordon Clements, Bristol council鈥檚 for BSF. 鈥淎ll three bidding teams had strong practices that carried out exemplar designs in 2004. We went through extended interviews with lots of detailed evaluation, and we had a terrific CABE enabler in John Jenner of architect Greenhill Jenner. We also made it clear from the start that we expected design modifications as part of the process.

鈥淪o the whole bidding process from initial bids to financial close took just over a year. It was longer than expected, but there was a desire to do things properly.鈥�

Although delighted to win the project, Wilkinson Eyre鈥檚 Critchlow discovered some weaknesses of the procurement method, as well as strengths. The Bristol BSF is a variant of the PFI, which along with design-and-build is the delivery method favoured by the DfES. Bids were invited that combined funding, design, construction and FM over 25 years. With its restrictions on time and dialogue with the teachers, the PFI process offers little scope for developing spatial concepts that would enhance the educational experience.

鈥淭here is no way we would have got to this concept without all the work we鈥檇 done on the exemplar design,鈥� he admits.

Both the pros and cons of PFI procurement were apparent on the project, according to Critchlow. 鈥淭he FM angle is upfront, so there鈥檚 a pretty thorough level of debate about things like catering and cleaning,鈥� he says. But he goes on point out that the PFI contractor controls the construction methods. 鈥淚n the conventional contract for the city academy in Reading, we proposed curtain walls, but in Bristol, the BSF contractor wants solid walls with punched-through windows.鈥�

The four schools designed by Wilkinson Eyre and built and managed by Skanska promise to transform the educational experience of their pupils. But whether Critchlow will be as happy with the build quality of the end result will not be known until September next year.