Victorian Society calls plans 鈥榰nacceptable鈥

Another heritage group has attacked Everton鈥檚 proposals for a 拢500m new stadium in Liverpool鈥檚 historic docks, a Unesco World Heritage Site.

The Victorian Society said the plans would cause 鈥渋ncontrovertible harm鈥 to the 1844 grade II-listed Bramley-Moore Dock, which closed to shipping last year.

It is the second heritage organisation to condemn the scheme, which would require infilling part of the dock. Historic England last week urged the government to call in and reject the proposals.

The Victorian Society conservation advisor Tom Taylor said: 鈥淐onsidered purely on the basis of conservation policy and principles, the proposals are unacceptable. 

鈥淭he decision-maker, whether the planning authority or Secretary of State, must be absolutely convinced that this is the only viable site for the stadium and that the predicted public benefits would outweigh the incontrovertible harm should consent be granted鈥.

Everton Stadium Overlay-2-EvertonBlue-BH (1)

Source:Pattern

Cross-section of the proposed stadium鈥檚 underlying structure

It comes the day after the club submitted revised designs of the scheme to Liverpool ciy council for planning.

Laing O鈥橰ourke is set to build the 52,888-seat stadium if it gets the green light.

Unveiled last month, the new designs have overhauled the stadium鈥檚 West Stand with a new stepped plaza and the removal of a multi-storey car park. The entire building has also been slightly reduced in height.

Everton stadium development director Colin Chong insisted the scheme, which is due to start on site early next year if approved, was a vibrant development which respects and reflects Liverpool鈥檚 dockland history and added that the revised designs would 鈥渇urther enhance and showcase the heritage of the site鈥.

But Historic England threw its weight against the plans, urging the government to make the final call on the application and recommending that it should be refused.

It said the proposal to infill the dock would 鈥渇undamentally change its historic character as a water-filled basin which so clearly tells the story of the docks and has contributed to its status as a World Heritage Site鈥.

It added that the application should be quashed 鈥渦nless the decision-maker concludes that the public benefits would outweigh the damage to Bramley-Moore dock and the harm to the World Heritage Site which the proposals would cause鈥.

The application is due to be sent in to Liverpool city council next month, with Chong telling supporters last month that planners may have to convene a special committee later this year to decide on the scheme due to its sheer size 鈥 one of the largest applications ever received by the local authority.

Project engineering consultant Buro Happold said this week that the Dan Meis-designed scheme will 鈥減reserve the integrity and heritage assets of the surrounding area for future generations鈥.

The firm released images from the scheme鈥檚 technical architect Pattern showing the underlying structure of the stadium.

Construction is due to start on site in 2021 if given the go-ahead.