Leading architects including Richard Rogers warn over lack of design scrutiny on 拢15bn project

ealing broadway crossrail

Ealing Broadway Crossrail station, submitted for planning this month, was not designed reviewed

The design of 27 surface stations on the 拢15bn Crossrail project is not being reviewed by independent experts, sparking warnings from leading architects and local authorities that rail bosses are missing a once-in-a-century chance to produce well-designed stations that will stand the test of time.

Since 2009, a dedicated Crossrail design review panel, set up by Design Council Cabe, has provided independent oversight on the eight new-build central London Crossrail stations, plus new stations at Abbey Wood and Woolwich.

Crossrail says the central London stations - by architects including Foster + Partners and John McAslan - feature 鈥渨orld-class design鈥 and build on a legacy stretching back to Charles Holden鈥檚 pre-war Tube stations and Brunel鈥檚 Paddington.

However, 好色先生TV has learned that Crossrail has chosen not to employ the design panel on the 27 redeveloped stations on the main surface section of the line, which stretches from Maidenhead in the west to Shenfield in the east and is managed by Network Rail as well as Crossrail.

This has sparked warnings that rail bosses are missing a once-in-a-century chance to produce well- designed stations.

Mark Lucas, head of planning and regeneration at the London Borough of Redbridge, which will have four Crossrail stations, said it was 鈥渧ery concerning鈥 that such developments would not be independently design reviewed.

He said: 鈥淭here is still time, but the door is closing. We鈥檙e in the last chance saloon.

鈥淭he last time stations on this branch of the tracks were created was in 1839, when the Victorians built them.

鈥淲hen you鈥檙e talking about something which should be lasting a century and a half, we really should be applying the greatest possible design scrutiny.鈥

Architect and Labour peer Richard Rogers said he was deeply concerned that Crossrail would not live up to the country鈥檚 鈥済reat railway heritage鈥 and vowed to lobby MPs on the issue.

鈥淭here has to be somebody who knows something about [design] looking at this,鈥 he said. 鈥淭his is immensely serious because [poor design] could scar the community which uses a station for a century or so. 

鈥淭hese are very important public buildings, which millions will travel through.鈥

A spokesperson for Cabe said the design panel 鈥渨ould welcome the opportunity to be involved in planning the remaining stations鈥 so that 鈥渢he vast knowledge that we built up around Crossrail also [benefits] towns and communities along the entire route鈥.

But a spokesperson for Crossrail said: 鈥淎 huge amount of time, effort and planning is going into delivering surface station enhancements.

鈥淲e believe that these improvements can be satisfactorily designed and delivered by working directly with local authorities.鈥


Expert concerns

Will Alsop, architect of North Greenwich station, Jubilee line extension

鈥淪tations should be uplifting, durable and beautiful. If Crossrail and its architects believe their designs are good, they have nothing to lose in having them design-reviewed.鈥

David Marks, co-founder of Marks Barfield Architects

鈥淲e did a number of earlier designs for Crossrail stations. We were brought on board by Transport for London to improve what was being offered but I don鈥檛 know what influence we had. I鈥檓 worried that we鈥檙e scrimping and saving and are not looking sufficiently to the long-term.鈥

Julian Bell, leader of Ealing council, a London borough with five Crossrail stations including Ealing Broadway

鈥淲e鈥檝e been very rigorous all along in seeking improvements to the stations we鈥檝e got.

鈥淒esign has been on the agenda but a body like Cabe, looking at things independently and adding rigorous standards, would be very welcome.鈥

Julian Lipscombe, director at Bennetts Associates, the architect working on 13 surface Crossrail stations including Ealing Broadway

鈥淲e are currently working closely with [local authorities] and Crossrail/Network Rail to maximise the potential of the schemes and would welcome a Cabe design review if requested.鈥