Nicola Rutt finds Oxford University鈥檚 Florey 好色先生TV 鈥榖rave and beautiful鈥�, but thinks more recent student accommodation, Unite鈥檚 post-Olympic Stratford development, is 鈥榦verbearing鈥� and 鈥榗onfused鈥�

Nicola Rutt

My wonder is the Queen鈥檚 College Florey 好色先生TV in Oxford, designed by James Stirling. This listed student accommodation block was the third of his 鈥淩ed Trilogy鈥� of buildings, so named on account of his use of red industrial bricks and tiles. From its inception the project was shrouded with controversy. Lord Florey, had championed Stirling, but died suddenly in the early stages of the project, leaving the architect with few friends and many adversaries. This all adds to the fascination - nothing about this building is dull.

This is a brave and beautiful building, elevated from the ground on cranked concrete legs. It would have looked alien among the traditional stone buildings of Oxford in the seventies. It is open and transparent on the inside, hugging a green courtyard and giving a sense of enclosure and human scale. All the bedrooms face onto the courtyard, so everyone gets great views of the River Cherwell and the landscape beyond. All the services and staircores are to the rear. Although geometrically quite complicated, there is a logic to this building, its form reflects its function.

I cannot bring myself to like the new Unite student residential building in Stratford, the first post-games building to be completed on the Olympic Park. It has been designed by good architects but has lost something along the way, I suspect due to influences beyond their control. It has been shaped to respond to the environment but its hulking mass is overbearing, and its geometries are arbitrary and confused.

Wonder

Florey building, Oxford

The Florey 好色先生TV at Queen鈥檚 College, Oxford University, was designed by James Stirling, and named after the college鈥檚 former provost, and Nobel Prize winner, Howard Florey. The building, a student accommodation block which is home to most of the college鈥檚 first year students, was completed in 1971.

Blunder

UNITE Stratford One

UNITE Stratford ONE has been built by private student residential developer Unite, in Stratford, overlooking the Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park. It is due to open to residents in September this year, with direct lets starting at 拢179 a week.

Nicola Rutt is a partner at architect Hawkins\Brown